10 Nov 2026 08:52:21
Been a while since I posted on here, no reason for why, other than just being busy.
Individual results and performances have been pretty bad, the Sunderland one putting a real exclamation point on that fact. But overall, from a league position perspective, we’re pretty much where I thought we’d be. At the start of the season I’d have been happy with top four and nothings changed, but you can’t drop points against Hull, Sunderland and Spurs whilst waiving the fans along saying nothing to see here, all is fine. The reality of the larger fan base under Blue Co is that it doesn’t take much to tip them over the edge into a toxic atmosphere. The team, and club, badly needs a run of positive results.
One thing that has become clear is the fact that Alonso doesn’t trust his squad, which, for me, is why he’s constantly tinkering with his first eleven. Welbeck and Emegha are clearly not trusted from the start, in the absence of Joao Pedro, whose loss massively impacts our effectiveness going forward - we don’t need to see Neto starting up top again.
I also get the impression he’d replace the entire defence, except Acheampong, given half a chance. Colwill has really struggled to shake off the rust of a missed season, I’m not sure he’s viewed as untouchable anymore and I certainly wouldn’t be surprised if he’s viewed as someone who can be upgraded in the first eleven for next season. Either way, we need a squad CB to replace Fofana, who looks full of mistakes. Palestra tools like he has all the foundations to be a good player, but his injury didn’t help him acclimatise to the EPL.
We’ve seen good individual performances in midfield from all of Caicedo, Henderson and Lavia, but no combination of them look like a midfield pivot around which the team can be built. The January addition of Scott (Is it certain? It seems certain!) will definitely help, and I think he’ll form that longterm starting pivot with Caicedo. Personal shout out for Barco, who I think has looked good in the limited opportunities he’s been given, positive on the ball, always looking forward.
I do think it’ll click into gear at some point and, come the end of the season, we’ll be comfortably positioned in the top four. But, no matter how much you prepare for what you know will be a transitional season, the unexpected points dropped aren’t easy to take / watch.
1.) 10 Nov 2026
10 Nov 2026 09:11:44
J, good to have you back mate.
As usual as very good post and I agree 100% with all your observations.
2.) 10 Nov 2026
10 Nov 2026 09:56:15
Good post J and I totally agree with you about our need for a dominant centre back which has to be the priority this January. Colwill is very weak and easily out muscled, Fofana is an accident waiting to happen and whilst Lacroix has done OK he is now out injured and who knows how he will come back, it leaves just Josh and Aaron A who is a rookie and just back from injury himself. A centre back of world class standing, strong, physical, composed and with experience will transform our season.
As for midfield, I really like the look of Lavia and it will be a travesty if the club replace him and partner someone else with Caicedo. We will regret that if it happens so for me let's leave the midfield alone and use Valentin as cover instead.
3.) 10 Nov 2026
10 Nov 2026 14:35:12
You can't rely on Lavia though, not to be a nailed on starter. As good as he is, it would be foolish to think the injury issues are behind him.
On Colwill, I think he just needs to be smarter. John Terry knew he wasn't the fastest, so never allowed himself to be in a position where he was going to be in a foot race with forwards. I'm not saying Colwill will ever be at that level, but he is getting into physical battles with strikers who out muscle him, he needs to play to his strengths.
4.) 10 Nov 2026
10 Nov 2026 16:23:43
J, I seem to remember JT saying you never get closer to CF than arms length. If you get touch tight, you risk getting rolled. Someone needs to have a word with Colwill because that is pretty basic stuff for a defender.
5.) 10 Nov 2026
10 Nov 2026 19:42:01
I was taught that from a very young age Tom, and not at a particularly high standard either.
6.) 11 Nov 2026
11 Nov 2026 09:07:19
So I guess the question is who is teaching Colwill now.
7.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 13:10:01
Given he was taken off at half time vs Sunderland, someone who doesn't think they're being listened to.
8.) 12 Nov 2026
12 Nov 2026 16:29:59
J
I think it was more to do with Colwill being on a yellow card that he was removed.
I still believe he is a top CB but for some reason it does not seem to be currently working for him under Alonso.
Hopefully that changes soon.